A well-designed Competent Person’s Report (CPR) gives sellers, bidders, lenders and regulators a common, independent view of an oil and gas asset’s reserves, resources, value and uncertainty. In a bid program, that shared assessment helps competing offers to be considered on a consistent basis. The report is most useful when its purpose, classification framework, scope, assumptions and limitations are agreed before the work begins.
What a CPR contributes to a bid program
A Competent Person’s Report is an independent assessment of an oil and gas asset’s reserves, resources and value, prepared and signed by a qualified professional. It provides a third-party view of the opportunity and the uncertainty around it. A seller can use the report to support an asking price, while bidders can use it to explain an offer to their boards and funders. Lenders and regulators also gain a common reference point for reviewing the asset.
Three features underpin a credible CPR:
- Independence: The author has no financial interest in the outcome and discloses relevant relationships.
- Competence: The signatory has appropriate qualifications and relevant experience. Exact requirements depend on the regulator, lender or exchange.
- Consistent standard: Resources are classified using a recognised framework, commonly the Petroleum Resources Management System (PRMS) developed by SPE and partner organisations.
Design the CPR around the decision
The scope should be designed backwards from the decision the report must support. A CPR prepared for bid evaluation may need a different emphasis from one intended for financing, licensing, acquisition or a listing. Before commissioning the work, settle seven programme elements:
- Purpose and audience: Confirm whether the report supports bid price assessment, licensing, acquisition, financing or listing.
- Competence and independence: Define qualifications, relevant experience, conflicts and sign-off requirements.
- Classification standard: Select one framework and agree consistent reporting categories.
- Scope of work: Specify the assets, report sections, depth of analysis and exclusions.
- Common assumptions: Agree the effective date, price deck, discount rate, fiscal terms, costs and abandonment basis.
- Data access and timing: Set data-room rules, Q&A windows, site visits and delivery dates.
- Review and release: Plan the draft, factual accuracy check, peer review and final signed report.
Define a bid-ready scope of work
The report should cover the technical and commercial elements needed to understand the asset, while making the bid-specific decision supported by each section clear. A consistent scope also makes it easier to compare assets and offers across a programme.
| Report section | What it covers | Bid-specific decision |
|---|---|---|
| Executive summary | Volumes, value range and key risks | One-page comparable summary |
| Asset description | Location, licence, history and infrastructure | Reuse of the seller data pack |
| Geology and geophysics | Structure, reservoir and seismic interpretation | Minimum data-quality requirements |
| Volumetrics | In-place and recoverable volumes; low, best and high estimates | Deterministic and/or probabilistic method |
| Production and development | Decline, well plans, facilities and timing | Approved development-plan basis |
| Economics | Cash flow, NPV, break-even and sensitivities | Common price deck, discount rate and fiscal terms |
| Risks and limitations | Technical, commercial, fiscal and political risks; reliance and disclosures | Common risk register and reliance terms |
Make every bidder assess the same evidence base.
A bid-ready CPR is more than a reserve or valuation summary. Its value comes from a defined scope, consistent assumptions, clearly separated resource classes and transparent limitations that let decision-makers understand both the opportunity and the uncertainty.
Talk to our teamClassify and risk resources transparently
Do not combine all volumes into one headline number. PRMS distinguishes commercial maturity first and uncertainty second. Keeping each class visible helps bidders understand what is commercially established and what remains conditional or exploratory.
| Class | Meaning | How bidders may treat it |
|---|---|---|
| Reserves (1P, 2P, 3P) | Commercially recoverable from an approved project or one with a clear route to approval | Highest confidence; typically central to bid value |
| Contingent resources (1C, 2C, 3C) | Discovered, but not yet commercial, for example while awaiting approval or infrastructure | Apply a development or commercialisation risk discount |
| Prospective resources (low, best, high) | Estimated volumes in undrilled prospects | Apply geological and commercial success probabilities |
For contingent and prospective resources, state the chance factors used, such as chance of geological success and chance of commercial development. Show un-risked and risked values separately. This keeps the underlying volume estimate distinct from the probability that it can be developed and commercialised.
Fix the data room and valuation basis
The valuation basis should be agreed before the CPR work begins. Late changes can force economic reruns and undermine bid comparability. The programme should document the following items and apply them consistently:
- Effective date: The date at which volumes and values are stated.
- Price deck: A named, common oil and gas price forecast, with any override rules stated.
- Fiscal terms: Royalties, taxes, profit share and cost-recovery terms under the licence or contract.
- Cost basis: CAPEX, OPEX, real or nominal terms, inflation and abandonment costs.
- Discount rate: A base case and sensitivities, for example 8%, 10% and 12%.
- Data-room rules: Information supplied, access period and a logged, consistently shared Q&A process.
- Sensitivities: Common price, volume, cost and timing cases for every bid.
A common data-room process matters as much as a common model. Bidder questions, supplied information and any clarifications should be logged and shared consistently under the agreed access rules. This helps avoid different bidders valuing the asset on materially different information or assumptions.
Avoid common CPR design mistakes
Several avoidable weaknesses can reduce the usefulness of a CPR in a bid process:
- Undefined purpose: A generic report may not answer the bid committee’s or lender’s actual questions.
- Blended resource classes: Combining reserves, contingent and prospective resources can overstate certainty.
- Different bidder assumptions: Different price decks or discount rates make offers difficult to compare.
- Weak independence: Success-linked fees or undisclosed relationships undermine credibility.
- Insufficient time: A compressed schedule leaves little room to address data gaps, complete factual checks or conduct peer review.
- Hidden limitations: Omitting data gaps, reliance terms or the basis of opinion weakens the report.
A CPR supports a stronger bid decision when its independence, resource classifications, valuation assumptions and limitations are visible to every relevant decision-maker.
Create a comparable basis for decisions
A credible CPR programme begins with the decision, then aligns the competent person, classification framework, scope, data access, valuation assumptions and review process around it. It keeps reserves, contingent resources and prospective resources distinct, and makes risk factors and limitations explicit. Those disciplines give sellers, bidders, lenders and regulators a shared basis for assessing the opportunity.
The report cannot remove uncertainty from an oil and gas asset. It can make that uncertainty understandable and comparable. For a bid program, that is the central purpose of a well-designed Competent Person’s Report.